It’s the Thought That Counts. So Why Do I Have to Keep it?
Holiday consumerism, sentimental clutter and the things we hold on to out of guilt.
It’s that time of the year again… when you go to buy a bag of Halloween candy only to be greeted by a winter wonderland of Christmas trees, inflatable Santas, and gift wrap galore before you’ve even grabbed a shopping cart.
Joy to the world, hyper consumerism strikes again!
It’s also the special time of year when Great Aunt Sally lugs Santa’s sack of crap to your house only for you to be standing there on January 2nd in a sea of plastic and “Made in China” stickers.
Jokes aside, I love the holidays. I love decorating, giving thoughtful gifts, and making a home feel festive. But somewhere along the way, celebrating became synonymous with consuming. And frankly, I think we’ve lost the plot.
As a professional organizer, I spend a lot of time sorting through the aftermath of our collective shopping habits. Closets filled with jeans we swore we would fit into by this Thanksgiving. Storage rooms packed with decorations that haven’t seen daylight in years. Cabinets housing enough serving ware to host Hanukkah for the entire neighborhood. And perhaps most interestingly, the things people don’t even want but feel obligated to keep.
I come across it on almost every project. The handmade artwork from a relative you would sooner burn than hang in your hallway. Grandmas “fine” china that is neither dishwasher- nor- microwave safe. Or the metal tin from the bookclub cookie exchange that now lives in your junk drawer. These objects occupy a strange place in our homes. We don’t necessarily love them. We don’t always use them. But getting rid of them feels like getting rid of the person, the memory, or the sentiment attached.
When did appreciating a gift become a lifelong commitment to keeping it?
Of course, there are exceptions. Some possessions hold memories that simply can’t be replaced. But I think we’d all benefit from recognizing that the meaning of an object and our obligation to keep it are two very different things.
Which highlights another consumerism qualm this time of year: holiday decorations.
Some of my favorite festive finds have come second hand from Goodwill or antique stores. Beautiful, high quality and affordable pieces that you know sat lovingly on someones mantel while the snow flurried outside.
Or maybe they didn’t!
That’s the beauty of letting your stuff go! Not only do you reclaim your space for things you actually like, but you give someone else the gift of creating new sentimental value.
Maybe that's what we should be thinking about when we give gifts in the first place. Not how much we can buy, but how much meaning we can give. A thoughtful present doesn’t necessarily have to be a physical object. It could be an experience, a dinner together, a service that makes someone’s life easier, or something that can be enjoyed without taking up permanent residence in their basement.
The bottom line on sentimental clutter
I’m certainly not suggesting we stop giving gifts or decorating for the holidays, but maybe we move with more intention about what we bring into our homes, what we give to others, and what we allow ourselves to let go of.
Because it’s the thought that counts, not the shelf space.
Sam helps clients across Chicago and the North Shore — from Evanston and Wilmette to Winnetka, Glenview, Highland Park and Lake Forest — sort sentimental belongings and holiday overflow with care.
Letting go of sentimental clutter, answered
How do I let go of sentimental items without feeling guilty?
Separate what an object means from any obligation to keep it. Keep the pieces you truly love or use, and let the rest go to someone who can give them new sentimental value.
What should I do with gifts I don’t want to keep?
Pass them on through donation, resale or a secondhand shop. Sam offers donation and haul-away, so unwanted items actually leave the house.
Can a professional organizer help sort sentimental belongings?
Yes. Sam works alongside clients across Chicago and the North Shore to sort sentimental belongings with care, offering an outside perspective and gentle help with the tough decisions.
Do you work outside the city, on the North Shore?
Yes. Sam works with clients throughout Chicago and across the North Shore, including Evanston, Wilmette, Kenilworth, Winnetka, Glencoe, Glenview, Northbrook, Highland Park and Lake Forest.